Sarah Schmeiser and I pick up the Cornell case where we left off. New York's governor pulled the case from the local DA and handed it to Attorney General Letitia James. Megyn Kelly said she'd name Jane Doe if her identity came out. And Jane Doe's lawyer says she's being threatened to drop her suit. We talk about who gets to prosecute when a DA says no, including Wisconsin's private-complaint statute and State ex rel. Kalal v. Circuit Court, a case Sarah was a party to before she was a lawyer. We also cover why "believe all women" doesn't help victims in a courtroom, how New York and Wisconsin differ on intoxication and consent, and why the mob is running the same play against both the accused and the accuser. This episode discusses sexual assault. Listener discretion advised. Chapters 00:00 Since we last recorded 00:21 Welcome back, Sarah 01:13 Wisconsin's private-prosecution statute and the Kalal case 10:43 The governor takes the case: oversight or politics? 13:39 Why "believe all women" fails victims in court 15:18 Victims' wishes, Marsy's Law, and prosecutorial discretion 22:52 Intoxication and consent: New York vs. Wisconsin 23:56 The ceiling-tile brief 28:28 Affirmative consent, "word or deed" 30:51 Vigilantism: threats, confrontations, and vandalism 33:30 Megyn Kelly says she'll name Jane Doe 38:25 Jonathan Ross, and checking ourselves 40:28 Flip the story: empathy before outrage 43:20 Next time: sexual ethics and double standards Part one: • Cornell, Consent, and the Culture War: Wha... anthonyjohn.esq
Sarah Schmeiser and I come back to the Cornell case after a week that moved fast: Gov. Kathy Hochul removed the Tompkins County DA and named Attorney General Letitia James special prosecutor, Megyn Kelly said she'd publish Jane Doe's name if it came out, and Jane Doe's lawyer says she's been threatened to drop her lawsuit.
In this episode:
How Wisconsin lets a private citizen ask a judge for a criminal complaint when the DA won't act, and the case that made that law famous, State ex rel. Kalal v. Circuit Court, 2004 WI 58. Sarah was one of the complainants.
Why "believe all women" is the wrong standard for a courtroom, and why it hurts the victims it's meant to protect.
New York's "voluntary intoxication" gap vs. Wisconsin's knowledge-based statute, and the ceiling-tile hypothetical from my 2018 brief to the Wisconsin Court of Appeals.
Vigilantism against the accused and the accuser, and checking our own outrage.
Clarification: New York treats a person who is unconscious, or "physically unable to communicate unwillingness," as incapable of consent however she got that way. The gap is for someone conscious but impaired by substances she took herself. (N.Y. Penal Law §§ 130.00, 130.05.)
This episode discusses sexual assault.
Sources
Megyn Kelly: "If her identity is revealed, I am going to name her" (Media Matters)
Cornell accuser faces threats demanding she drop her lawsuit (NBC News)
Watch on YouTube · Part one: Cornell, Consent, and the Culture War